Calibrating the minimum-norm receiver
How much must you measure for C2⋆ to be real? This bench calibrates the manuscript's maximum-capture receiver with a population-only protocol over K templates, with shot and phase noise, and pinpoints why it fails when it fails. Every figure cites its origin.
Worst-mode capture vs K
Noiseless, with noise (median and 16–84% band), and the exact optimum of Theorem 1. K = 3 reproduces C2.
Fraction of each mode outside the basis
Leakage ε_K = 1 − ‖P_Kφ‖². It is the capture lost by truncating the basis; it causes no crosstalk.
Selectivity vs shots
Median and 16–84% band over 40 realisations. Unit slope is the law Σ ∝ M.
Realisability of the most demanding filter
Normalised profile of the calibrated filter against the absorption limit ρ_B F. Red marks where the control does not exist.
Diagnosis: what fails, where and why
Six results, each with its level of evidence
DEM = proved in the manuscript; VER = verified numerically on this bench; CONJ = reasonable conjecture awaiting proof.
Capture of a normalised dualDEM
Any filter that exactly nulls the other modes pays its excess norm as lost capture. The problem is therefore choosing the minimum-norm dual.
Theorem 1: the optimum lives in span{φ}DEM
Proof idea
A component orthogonal to span{φ} changes no overlap and spends norm. Inside the span, nulling the other modes forces h ∝ Qφm, with Q the projector orthogonal to them; ‖Qφm‖² = 1/(G−1)mm by the Schur complement.
Calibrating with K templates is projectingVER
The calibrated receiver is the C2⋆ of the projected modes. With K = 3 and span{φ̂} = span{f}, the dual is unique and equals C2. As K grows, the leakage εK = 1 − ‖PKφ‖² falls and η(K) climbs to η*.
Why crosstalk is zero without noise
The filter lies in span{f0…fK−1}, so ⟨h|φn⟩ = ⟨h|PKφn⟩: the part of φ outside the basis is invisible. Truncation therefore costs capture, not crosstalk.
Gauge invarianceDEM
With D diagonal and unitary, the diagonal of G−1 is unchanged and each filter only picks up a global phase. The bench checks this with random phases: the difference is of order 10−16.
Noise law: Σ ∝ MVER
Estimation error breaks duality at first order in δS, and crosstalk is quadratic in that error. With a well-conditioned G, Σ ≈ 2M in this model. An ill-conditioned G amplifies the error by cond(G).
The calibration templates must be absorbable tooCONJ
The population protocol absorbs template superpositions. The most demanding in the family is (f₀ + f₁)/√2, because of the same time asymmetry studied in bench TM-01. That this protocol suffices to recover G without quadrature access is the conjecture this bench supports but does not prove.
Tests of the core and of the page's claims
Auditor's findings
What this bench does not model
- The link is chiral with no delay; ETH uses a 30 m bidirectional link where the rejected mode returns after ≈ 292 ns.
- The envelope distortion is a causal filter (proxy), not the manuscript's a = 0.150 miscalibration.
- No emitter control noise, qubit decoherence, or drift between calibration and operation.
- Calibration noise is a first-order model; the real population protocol has its own estimator and biases.
- Templates f₃ … f₇ extend the ETH family by Gram–Schmidt of τk sech(τ/2); ETH uses only f₀ … f₂.
- Calibration time uses an assumed repetition rate, not an ETH figure.
- The manuscript’s Σ ≈ 3.6×10³ reference is a favourable noise realisation: over 40 seeds the median is ≈ 2.1×10³ (bench TM-05).
Reproducible, sealed record
Parameters, seed and results for the current configuration, with its SHA-256 fingerprint to pre-register a prediction.